How to calculate whether your rental property can carry a higher mortgage payment in 2026
The first stress test most landlords skip is the one that matters: what happens when the property costs more per month than it brings in. That gap appears at renewal faster than most expect, and it's arithmetic, not speculation.
Start with two numbers that don't move. Your monthly rent and your current mortgage payment. In September 2026, if a Victoria single-family rental brings in $2,800/month and the existing mortgage payment is $1,950/month, the gap before expenses is $850. That's the space you have to work with. Every other cost comes out of that $850.
Build the expense floor
Property tax, insurance, strata fees if applicable. For a BC property, assume roughly $250/month property tax, $125/month insurance, and if it's a condo add another $350/month strata. That's $725/month before anything breaks. Your $850 gap is now $125.
Repairs and maintenance run about 1% of property value annually as a planning figure, though actual bills are lumpy. On a $750,000 property that's $7,500/year, or $625/month if you spread it evenly. You're now negative $500/month before vacancy.
Vacancy and turnover cost more than the rent you don't collect. A week between tenants, cleaning, minor repairs, maybe a month when someone leaves mid-lease. Budget 5% of annual rent. On $2,800/month that's $1,680/year, or $140/month averaged. You're now at a $640/month shortfall.
The property was break-even when the mortgage was $1,950. It stops being break-even the moment the payment rises above $1,950 plus that original $850 gap. In other words, $2,800. Anything past that requires cash from somewhere else.
Calculate the new payment
Your renewal rate determines the payment. Assume you're renewing a $500,000 balance with 20 years left. At 4.5%, the monthly payment is roughly $3,165. At 5.5%, it's $3,435. At 6.5%, it's $3,710.
The existing payment was $1,950, which implies you either borrowed less originally, had a longer loan repayment period (the time it takes to pay off the mortgage completely), or locked in when rates were lower. That history doesn't matter. What matters is the new payment against the same rental income.
At 4.5%, the new payment is $3,165. Monthly rent is still $2,800. You're short $365 before expenses, or about $1,000/month after the full expense stack. You need $12,000/year in cash to hold the property.
At 5.5%, the shortfall grows to $635 before expenses, or roughly $1,275/month after. That's $15,300/year.
At 6.5%, you're looking at a $910 pre-expense gap, or about $1,550/month all-in. Call it $18,600/year from other income or savings.
Where lenders give credit
When you renew, the lender recalculates your qualifying income using the stress test: contract rate plus 200 hundredths of one percent (a measurement used to describe small changes in interest rates), or 5.25%, whichever is higher. If you're renewing at 4.5%, you qualify at 6.5%. If you're renewing at 5.5%, you qualify at 7.5%.
Rental income counts, but only partially. Lenders credit 50% to 80% of gross rent toward your income, depending on the institution and your tax filing history. On $2,800/month, that's $1,400 to $2,240/month, or $16,800 to $26,880/year. The rental property itself contributes qualifying income, but not enough to offset the full new payment if rates have moved significantly.
If your employment income and the rental credit together don't support the stressed payment, the lender can decline the renewal or require a lump-sum payment to bring the balance down.
The flip condition
This calculation reverses when rents rise faster than mortgage costs or when you've paid down enough principal that the balance is materially lower at renewal. A property that required cash top-ups in 2026 can return to positive cash flow by 2029 if rents climb $300/month and the mortgage balance drops $50,000. The decision isn't whether the property loses money this year. It's whether you can carry it through the loss period until the math turns.
Run the numbers with your actual rent, your actual balance, and the rate your lender quotes at renewal. If the gap is $500/month, that's $6,000/year. If it's $1,500/month, that's $18,000. Know the number before you renew, not after.
The first stress test most landlords skip is the one that matters: what happens when the property costs more per month than it brings in. That gap appears at renewal faster than most expect, and it's arithmetic, not speculation.
Start with two numbers that don't move. Your monthly rent and your current mortgage payment. In September 2026, if a Victoria single-family rental brings in $2,800/month and the existing mortgage payment is $1,950/month, the gap before expenses is $850. That's the space you have to work with. Every other cost comes out of that $850.
Build the expense floor
Property tax, insurance, strata fees if applicable. For a BC property, assume roughly $250/month property tax, $125/month insurance, and if it's a condo add another $350/month strata. That's $725/month before anything breaks. Your $850 gap is now $125.
Repairs and maintenance run about 1% of property value annually as a planning figure, though actual bills are lumpy. On a $750,000 property that's $7,500/year, or $625/month if you spread it evenly. You're now negative $500/month before vacancy.
Vacancy and turnover cost more than the rent you don't collect. A week between tenants, cleaning, minor repairs, maybe a month when someone leaves mid-lease. Budget 5% of annual rent. On $2,800/month that's $1,680/year, or $140/month averaged. You're now at a $640/month shortfall.
The property was break-even when the mortgage was $1,950. It stops being break-even the moment the payment rises above $1,950 plus that original $850 gap. In other words, $2,800. Anything past that requires cash from somewhere else.
Calculate the new payment
Your renewal rate determines the payment. Assume you're renewing a $500,000 balance with 20 years left. At 4.5%, the monthly payment is roughly $3,165. At 5.5%, it's $3,435. At 6.5%, it's $3,710.
The existing payment was $1,950, which implies you either borrowed less originally, had a longer loan repayment period (the time it takes to pay off the mortgage completely), or locked in when rates were lower. That history doesn't matter. What matters is the new payment against the same rental income.
At 4.5%, the new payment is $3,165. Monthly rent is still $2,800. You're short $365 before expenses, or about $1,000/month after the full expense stack. You need $12,000/year in cash to hold the property.
At 5.5%, the shortfall grows to $635 before expenses, or roughly $1,275/month after. That's $15,300/year.
At 6.5%, you're looking at a $910 pre-expense gap, or about $1,550/month all-in. Call it $18,600/year from other income or savings.
Where lenders give credit
When you renew, the lender recalculates your qualifying income using the stress test: contract rate plus 200 hundredths of one percent (a measurement used to describe small changes in interest rates), or 5.25%, whichever is higher. If you're renewing at 4.5%, you qualify at 6.5%. If you're renewing at 5.5%, you qualify at 7.5%.
Rental income counts, but only partially. Lenders credit 50% to 80% of gross rent toward your income, depending on the institution and your tax filing history. On $2,800/month, that's $1,400 to $2,240/month, or $16,800 to $26,880/year. The rental property itself contributes qualifying income, but not enough to offset the full new payment if rates have moved significantly.
If your employment income and the rental credit together don't support the stressed payment, the lender can decline the renewal or require a lump-sum payment to bring the balance down.
The flip condition
This calculation reverses when rents rise faster than mortgage costs or when you've paid down enough principal that the balance is materially lower at renewal. A property that required cash top-ups in 2026 can return to positive cash flow by 2029 if rents climb $300/month and the mortgage balance drops $50,000. The decision isn't whether the property loses money this year. It's whether you can carry it through the loss period until the math turns.
Run the numbers with your actual rent, your actual balance, and the rate your lender quotes at renewal. If the gap is $500/month, that's $6,000/year. If it's $1,500/month, that's $18,000. Know the number before you renew, not after.
Read Next
The Expensive Relief of Locking in at the Top
A 4% Mortgage Qualifies at 6%: Reading the Stress Test Correctly in 2026
Economists Forecast Interest Rates as a Herd, and Borrowers Pay for the Misses
Rents Move Last: Read Employer Investment to Spot Demand 18 to 24 Months Early